Girl
Guides will no longer pledge their devotion to God when they join the
organisation, it has been announced.
The
phrase "to love my God" has been dropped from the Promise
after a consultation suggested different words are needed to include
the non-religious.
Instead,
girls joining the organisation will now be asked to "be true to
myself and develop my beliefs".
This
kind of dumbing down, this increasing taste for statements that are
inoffensive to the point of being meaningless, is beyond satire.
You'd think that by now organisations would have learned the lesson
from the Anglican Church that by trying to be 'all things to all
men', you end up being nothing to anyone.
Our
Father who..
Well,
when I say “Our”,
I don't mean to exclude people of other faiths or none, and when I
say “Father”
I mean no offence to the millions of wonderful Mothers in the world,
though I am not suggesting that to be fulfilled, a woman has to be a
mother. OK, let's try again:
One's
Parent, who art in Heaven...
Not
wishing to be prescriptive about grammatical forms – let's face it,
it's communication not correctness that matters – we need to do
something about that 'art',
by choosing from such popular alternatives as 'am' 'is' and 'are'.
So, let's try again:
One's
parent who am is or are in Heaven....
This
'Heaven'
concept could be too narrow for the many people who just believe
there “must be something....” How about:
One's
Parent, who am is or are in a Nicer Place, hallowed be thy name...
Oh
dear, how many people know what 'hallowed'
means (I don't LOL!!) - and that word 'thy'
has to go in case it implies we are all from Lancashire. Oh dear,
it's too difficult. I think we need to revamp the whole prayer.
Something simple like:
Thank
you, whoever you are for whatever it is, amen.
I
reckon the Girl Guides would like that one.
2 comments:
'Dumbing down' as you say. The most offensive thing any Minister can do to his congregation is to 'talk down' to them. Fortunately for them, the ones I have known who do this are too dim to realise they're doing it.
I find dumbing down to be not only offensive, but, worse,destructive. So many things bother me these days, I reckon I must be getting old.
Post a Comment